Thank you for such an answer.
The stakes are high...
Man cannot undo what God has enjoined: Jesus declared the Office and it has/will not "fall" as you say.
What I said was that there is no height from which man cannot fall...
If Lucifer became Satan, the Pope can fall...
Peter, you see, was not even the Pope of Jerusalem -
That man was James, the brother of the Lord,
who presided over the Council in Jerusalem regarding the discipling of the Gentiles,
which followed the argument Peter made...
You see, the delegates AGREED with Peter -
He did not COMMAND their agreement,
which a Pope or Patriarch can do with his own Bishops...
Jesus said: "The scribes and the Pharisees have taken Moses' Seat,
therefore do all they enjoin upon you,
but don't act as they do."
The treasury is not in the authority of the office...
It is in the obedience of the person...
Jesus himself shows the Office does not fail- and Christians must obey and honor the Office, while knowing right behavior from wrong on an individual level!
Jesus shows Himself that HE does not fail, for He is God... When Peter confessed Christ as God, Jesus said:
Blessed are you Bar jonah...
Why did He say this? He goes on to say:
For flesh and blood has not revealed this to you...
So then who DID reveal it to Simon?
But My Father in the Heavens
So that we have established the revelation to man of Who Christ IS by the Father of Christ in the heavens as the cause of the blessedness of that man to whom it has been revealed in this manner...
Then Christ goes on to say, giving Simon his new name:
But also TO YOU I am saying:
YOU are Peter...
Why would He name him Peter? It is because of the nature of his confession, its content and its source:
And upon this very rock...
The rock of Simon-now-Peter's Divinely Revealed Confession of Who Christ IS... The very Christ Who IS the Rock and Cornerstone of the Church...
I will construct OF ME the Ekklesia...
The placement of the possessive "OF ME" between "will construct" and "the Ekklesia"
signifies its distribution between the two,
for both is the construction "of Christ",
but also the Church is "Christ's"...
Indeed, the Church is the Body "of Christ"...
And the name Peter is masculine,
but the person of Peter is not that upon which the Church
[which Himself Christ will build] is to be constructed...
Were that true, the Greek would have read Rock, and not rock,
and Rock would have been in the masculine as is Peter,
but it is in the feminine - petra, and not the masculine, Petron...
The Greek for "confession" is a feminine noun
that agrees in gender nicely with the feminine noun petra, or rock...
And it was in their war-loving vanity that the German Bishops
took the Chief Apostle's words to mean themselves personally
when they took over the Papacy at the end of the first millennium...
When the Church had been built on the confession of who Christ IS,
the Nicene Creed,
for the first thousand years...
And in this, they ALSO altered that confession
by thee ADDITION of the FALSE Filioque...
And this constituted the Fall of the Papacy into schizmatic and doctrinal ERROR...
They were sincere...
They came to Constantinople and DEMANDED
that the Greek Speaking Church Fathers RESTORE the Filioque
which they had REMOVED from the Creed...
Such was the lie...
They thought that we had removed words from the Creed,
the confession upon which Christ had built Christ's Church...
Such was the error of the power-sated Latin Papal Authorities...
And it continues to this day...
God bless you, my Friend...
Arsenios