agape
New member
Kevin,
Agape,
quote:
--------------------------------------------------------------------------------
I don't know how many times I have said that we need to remain within the context. "Save" in the context, is not talking about save in light of Romans 10:9. It is talking about saved in the sense of being whole in one's soul and physical well being, delivered from hurt or harm...etc. He gives the explanation of "save" in the context.
---------------------------------------------------------------------------------
Agape,
quote:
--------------------------------------------------------------------------------
I don't know how many times I have said that we need to remain within the context. "Save" in the context, is not talking about save in light of Romans 10:9. It is talking about saved in the sense of being whole in one's soul and physical well being, delivered from hurt or harm...etc. He gives the explanation of "save" in the context.
---------------------------------------------------------------------------------
OBVIOUSLYI don't quite understand what you're getting at.
There you go again...TWISTING MY WORDS. I SAID THAT THE WORD SAVED IN JAMES IS NOT TALKING ABOUT SOMEONE GETTING SAVED, BORN AGAIN. I SAID THAT THE JAMES IS TALKING TO THOSE WHO ALREADY HAVE FAITH AND THEREFORE, IF YOU REMAIN WITHIN THE CONTEXT OF CHAPTER 2 THE WORD "SAVED" DOES NOT MEAN SAVED IN LIGHT OF ROMANS 10:9. SAVED, IN LIGHT OF FAITH WITHOUT WORKS HERE IN JAMES, NOT EPHESIANS 2:8,9, MEANS TO MAKE WHOLE THAT WHICH IS LACKING. TO DELIVER ONE FROM HURT OR HARM AND THE REST I SAID.If you're insisting that this faith only effects the physical well-being of a person, you are wrong.
James is not teaching anyone to get saved and born again. He is teaching about the faith they already have BECAUSE they are ALREADY SAVED AND BORN AGAIN. Having this FAITH WITHOUT WORKS profits no one...it is as dead, no life to the faith that they already have...AND IN THIS SENSE, it does have affect on one's salvation in that IT IS NOT BEING UTILIZED.James is speaking about the same faith in all of the chapters of his book, which certainly does effect our salvation.
Yes...and what does he preach about the already faith? He preached that that faith, without works" is dead, unprofitable.The Bible speaks that there is one faith that matters in terms of salvation, and James would preach that faith.
Oh baloney. That's your own private interpretation. James makes mention of NO SUCH THING. This is an example of you twisting not only my words around, but God's Word too. Show me where it states what you say it means in James 2. Does James even mention about hell fire or being damned???.The word "save" in James 2 certainly has a bearing on salvation, it speaks of the same type of works that condemned the people to hell in Matt 25:41-46.
It's obvious here that you are the one who has no proof and that you haven't a clue to what James 2 is really talking about and that's because you are reading your own theory into it instead of allowing the Word to interpret itself.You have NO evidence to suggest that James would talk about a faith that does not have a bearing on our salvation.
Here, listen closely, and maybe you'll understand what I've been trying to tell you. Works does NOT save us. Works plays a role in our salvation. Yes, believe it or not, God actually requires us to DO something to be saved.
Works do not save or get anyone born again. However, works AFTER we are saved and born again does play an important role in our walking in what we have already received at the time of the new birth. We put our faith into action and make it work for us and for others. See how simple it all is?There is a difference between works saving us, and having works play a role in our salvation.
Here is another way I can simply put it.
Ephesians 2:8,9:
For by grace are ye saved through faith; and that not of yourselves: [it is] the gift of God:
Not of works, lest any man should boast.
Ok...God says we are SAVED THROUGH FAITH, NOT OF WORKS. CLEAR AND SIMPLE. NO IFS, ANDS OR BUTS ABOUT IT
Now let's compare the above verse with James
James 2:14-17:
What [doth it] profit, my brethren, though a man say he hath faith, and have not works? can faith save him?
If a brother or sister be naked, and destitute of daily food,
And one of you say unto them, Depart in peace, be [ye] warmed and filled; notwithstanding ye give them not those things which are needful to the body; what [doth it] profit?
Even so faith, if it hath not works, is dead, being alone.
What does it profit a man if he hath faith (already has faith) and not any works (does nothing with his faith), can faith WITHOUT WORKS save him? Can just having faith alone , no works or action taken on that faith "save," "deliver," "keep whole" a brother or sister who is naked and destitute of daily food.
See the difference?
Is James saying can faith, without works, save according to Romans 10:9?? NO. Is James saying that faith without works will send someone to hell?? Absolutely NO.
He is saying, according to the example he gives, that one who has faith and does not put it into action cannot save one FROM being naked and hungry. Action must be taken in order to help or deliver anyone from whatever need he/she may have.
If we have faith and are saved and born again of God's Spirit and we do nothing with the faith we have, allowing it to remain dormant, we, nor those around us, will not receive the blessings and benefits that come along with faith as a living reality.
Kevin, you say that works does not SAVE us...then at the same time you say that God requires us to DO WORKS to BE SAVED. You also falsely state that James is saying if no works they will go to hell. So HOW CAN YOU SAY WORKS CANNOT SAVE US? I really think you are being spiritually blinded and you cannot see how you are twisting God's Word around. This is not to be nasty or critical, Kevin, but I suggest that you pray to God to remove the spiritual blindness from your eyes so that you can see what the Scriptures are truly saying.
God bless you.