Murray Rothbard on Tearing Down “Civil War” Statues
Thomas DiLorenzo
In his 1994 essay, “Just War,” Murray Rothbard concluded:
“n this War Between the States, the South may have fought for its sacred honor, but the Northern war was the very opposite of honorable. *We remember the care with which the civilized nations had developed classical international law. *Above all, civilians must not be targeted; wars must be limited. *But the North insisted on creating a conscript army, a nation in arms, and broke the 19th-century rules of war by specifically plundering and slaughtering civilians, by destroying civilian life and institutions so as to reduce the South to submission. *Sherman’s famous march through Georgia was one of the great war crimes, and crimes against humanity, of the past half century-and-a-half. *Because by targeting and butchering civilians, Lincoln and Grant and Sherman paved the way for all the genocidal horrors of the monstrous 20th century. *There has been a lot of talk in recent years about memory, about never forgetting about history as retroactive punishment for crimes of war and mass murder. *As Lord Acton, the great libertarian historian, put it, the historian, in the last analysis, must be a moral judge. *The muse of the historian, he wrote, is not Clio, but Rhadamanthus, the legendary avenger of innocent blood. *In that spirit, we must always remember, we must never forget, we must put in the dock and hang higher than Haman, those who, in modern times, opened the Pandora’s Box of genocide and the extermination of civilians: *Sherman, Grant, and Lincoln.
Perhaps, some day, their statues,like Lenin’s in Rusia, will be toppled and melted down; their insignias and battle flags will be desecrated, their war songs tossed into the fire. *And then Davis and Lee and Jackson and Forrest, and all the heroes of the South, “Dixie,” and the Stars and Bars, will once again be truly honored and remembered . . . . *I am sure that one day, aided and abetted by Northerners like myself in the glorious “copperhead” tradition, the South shall rise again.”