So I am. Jesus is saying that "... you were under the tree when/where I saw you, before Phillip called you."
What is wrong with that?
To me or someone else? I think you are correct.
Another point: "Before" Nathaniel met Jesus. That Jesus would even know Nathaniel was coming is also a mark of omnipresence and omniscience. -Lon
In some ways, it is good, because here is a website where all comers interact whether they are from orthodox, heterodox, heretical, or anti-thesis positions. You just have to know who you are interacting with.I just found it "odd" that the "religious" section would NOT be where "scholarly biblical conversation" would take place.
Maranatha