jshugart
New member
Whom do you follow?
Seems like a simple question really. But what if two different people, with two different Gospels are both telling you to follow them? I would think it would matter who the two people were.
Jesus says in so many verses to follow him. [Matt 4:19, Matt 16:24, Matt 19:28, Mark 1:17, Mark 10:21, Luke 5:27, Luke 18:22, John 1:43, John 8:12, John 21:19]
Paul says to follow him. [1 Cor 4:16, 1 Cor 11:1, Gal 4:12, Phil 3:17, 1 Thess 1:6, 2 Thess 3:7,9]
This one is important:
1Cor 11:1 (HCSB)
"Imitate me, as I also imitate Christ."
So here, Paul is explicitly telling people to follow him, because if they do that, they will also be following Christ, because Paul imitates Christ. None of the other Apostles tell us to follow or imitate them, just Paul. That is a very interesting claim, that Paul imitates Christ.
A claim that I say doesn’t hold up under scrutiny.
Let us compare what Jesus and Paul have to say on about some topics.
A) Concerning payments for preaching the gospel:
Jesus – Matt 10:7-8
Paul – 1 Tim 5:17-18, 1 Cor 9:11-12
B) Concerning sacrifices to God:
Jesus – Matt 9:13
Paul – 1 Cor 5:7, Eph 5:2
C) Concerning unconditional election:
Jesus – Matt 7:21-22
Paul – Rom 9:16
D) Concerning the identity and number of leaders, pastors (shepherds), teachers:
Jesus – Matt 23:8, 10, John 10:16,
Paul – 1 Cor 4:15, Eph 4:11, 1 Cor 12:28, 1 Tim 2:7, 2 Tim 1:11
E) Concerning the number to be saved:
Jesus – Matt 7:13-14
Paul – Rom 11:25-26
F) Concerning the destiny of the Law and the Prophets:
Jesus – Matt 5:17-20
Paul – Rom 10:4 *
* IMO: Rom 10:4 should use the alt reading of “goal” instead of “end”. If it is “goal”, then Paul is agreeing with Jesus, and this item should be removed from this list. However, if the correct reading is “end” as my father tells me is the only “correct” reading, then Paul is in disagreement with Jesus, and this item belongs on the list.
G) Concerning the destiny of the ‘heavens and earth’:
Jesus – Matt 24:35
Paul – Rom 8:21
H) Concerning qualifying for eternal life:
Jesus – John 5:24
Paul – Rom 5:21
I) Concerning your father:
Jesus – Matt 23:9
Paul – 1 Cor 4:15, Phlm 1:10
J) Concerning the commandments and eternal life:
Jesus – Matt 19:17
Paul – Rom 7:9-10
K) Concerning the basis of judgment:
Jesus – John 12:48
Paul – Rom 2:12
L) Concerning the cost of eternal life:
Jesus – Matt 19:29
Paul – Luke 14:28, 33
M) Concerning being justified:
Jesus – Matt 12:37
Paul – Rom 3:24, 28, Rom 5:9
N) Concerning forgiveness of trespasses:
Jesus – Matt 6:14-15
Paul – Eph 1:7, Rom 4:25
O) Concerning whom God has mercy:
Jesus – Matt 5:7
Paul – Rom 9:15-18
P) Concerning the Sum of the Commandments:
Jesus – Matt 22:37-40
Paul – Rom 14:9
Q) Concerning the God of the Dead:
Jesus – Luke 20:38
Paul – Rom 14:9
R) Concerning the source of ‘truth’:
Jesus – John 17:14,17
Paul – 1 Cor 2:13, Gal 1:12
S) Concerning the coming of the Lord:
Jesus – Luke 21:8
Paul – Rom 13:12
T) Concerning swearing an oath:
Jesus – Matt 5:34-37
Paul – 1 Cor 1:23
You can’t serve two masters. Jesus and Paul teach vastly different doctrine, which is not compatible with each other.
I reject Paul, and I follow and imitate Jesus.
Whom do you follow?
Fair Warning:
I do not have the same canon as most. I reject the NT as “Scripture”, preferring to view the NT works as historical documents. I am quoting them here as historical fact, not as ‘Holy Scripture’.
I am not trying to change anyone else’s viewpoint; I am presenting this because my father, JerryShugart, wishes me to share on his favorite discussion forum.
This list is mainly to show why I believe what I believe. Why would I want to do that? I wouldn’t. I don’t care what anyone else believes. That is between them and their Creator. I do this because my father asked me to (Ex 20:12), so I have.
I am searching for truth. So if I have doctrine in error, I want to know why, so I can correct it. Let us keep things on topic please, if we allow this to go in any direction, we will have chaos.
All I ask is that you remember, I am not trying to convince you, if you join into the discussion it should be to convince me why my logic, reasoning, facts, etc is wrong or incorrect. I may not agree with you, but please don’t take that as a personal attack, I’m just explaining why I don’t agree.
Seems like a simple question really. But what if two different people, with two different Gospels are both telling you to follow them? I would think it would matter who the two people were.
Jesus says in so many verses to follow him. [Matt 4:19, Matt 16:24, Matt 19:28, Mark 1:17, Mark 10:21, Luke 5:27, Luke 18:22, John 1:43, John 8:12, John 21:19]
Paul says to follow him. [1 Cor 4:16, 1 Cor 11:1, Gal 4:12, Phil 3:17, 1 Thess 1:6, 2 Thess 3:7,9]
This one is important:
1Cor 11:1 (HCSB)
"Imitate me, as I also imitate Christ."
So here, Paul is explicitly telling people to follow him, because if they do that, they will also be following Christ, because Paul imitates Christ. None of the other Apostles tell us to follow or imitate them, just Paul. That is a very interesting claim, that Paul imitates Christ.
A claim that I say doesn’t hold up under scrutiny.
Let us compare what Jesus and Paul have to say on about some topics.
A) Concerning payments for preaching the gospel:
Jesus – Matt 10:7-8
Paul – 1 Tim 5:17-18, 1 Cor 9:11-12
B) Concerning sacrifices to God:
Jesus – Matt 9:13
Paul – 1 Cor 5:7, Eph 5:2
C) Concerning unconditional election:
Jesus – Matt 7:21-22
Paul – Rom 9:16
D) Concerning the identity and number of leaders, pastors (shepherds), teachers:
Jesus – Matt 23:8, 10, John 10:16,
Paul – 1 Cor 4:15, Eph 4:11, 1 Cor 12:28, 1 Tim 2:7, 2 Tim 1:11
E) Concerning the number to be saved:
Jesus – Matt 7:13-14
Paul – Rom 11:25-26
F) Concerning the destiny of the Law and the Prophets:
Jesus – Matt 5:17-20
Paul – Rom 10:4 *
* IMO: Rom 10:4 should use the alt reading of “goal” instead of “end”. If it is “goal”, then Paul is agreeing with Jesus, and this item should be removed from this list. However, if the correct reading is “end” as my father tells me is the only “correct” reading, then Paul is in disagreement with Jesus, and this item belongs on the list.
G) Concerning the destiny of the ‘heavens and earth’:
Jesus – Matt 24:35
Paul – Rom 8:21
H) Concerning qualifying for eternal life:
Jesus – John 5:24
Paul – Rom 5:21
I) Concerning your father:
Jesus – Matt 23:9
Paul – 1 Cor 4:15, Phlm 1:10
J) Concerning the commandments and eternal life:
Jesus – Matt 19:17
Paul – Rom 7:9-10
K) Concerning the basis of judgment:
Jesus – John 12:48
Paul – Rom 2:12
L) Concerning the cost of eternal life:
Jesus – Matt 19:29
Paul – Luke 14:28, 33
M) Concerning being justified:
Jesus – Matt 12:37
Paul – Rom 3:24, 28, Rom 5:9
N) Concerning forgiveness of trespasses:
Jesus – Matt 6:14-15
Paul – Eph 1:7, Rom 4:25
O) Concerning whom God has mercy:
Jesus – Matt 5:7
Paul – Rom 9:15-18
P) Concerning the Sum of the Commandments:
Jesus – Matt 22:37-40
Paul – Rom 14:9
Q) Concerning the God of the Dead:
Jesus – Luke 20:38
Paul – Rom 14:9
R) Concerning the source of ‘truth’:
Jesus – John 17:14,17
Paul – 1 Cor 2:13, Gal 1:12
S) Concerning the coming of the Lord:
Jesus – Luke 21:8
Paul – Rom 13:12
T) Concerning swearing an oath:
Jesus – Matt 5:34-37
Paul – 1 Cor 1:23
You can’t serve two masters. Jesus and Paul teach vastly different doctrine, which is not compatible with each other.
I reject Paul, and I follow and imitate Jesus.
Whom do you follow?
Fair Warning:
I do not have the same canon as most. I reject the NT as “Scripture”, preferring to view the NT works as historical documents. I am quoting them here as historical fact, not as ‘Holy Scripture’.
I am not trying to change anyone else’s viewpoint; I am presenting this because my father, JerryShugart, wishes me to share on his favorite discussion forum.
This list is mainly to show why I believe what I believe. Why would I want to do that? I wouldn’t. I don’t care what anyone else believes. That is between them and their Creator. I do this because my father asked me to (Ex 20:12), so I have.
I am searching for truth. So if I have doctrine in error, I want to know why, so I can correct it. Let us keep things on topic please, if we allow this to go in any direction, we will have chaos.
All I ask is that you remember, I am not trying to convince you, if you join into the discussion it should be to convince me why my logic, reasoning, facts, etc is wrong or incorrect. I may not agree with you, but please don’t take that as a personal attack, I’m just explaining why I don’t agree.