The Heroic Gunslinger Fantasy

ok doser

lifeguard at the cement pond
Saddam was playing footsie with UN inspectors wrt missles (defined by the UN as WMDs) that could reach Israel

Do you think he should have been allowed to develop the ability to deliver WMDs to Israel?
 
Last edited:

Granite

New member
Hall of Fame
Seriously...We are at a point in the history of this country's leadership where not "as stupid as..." is considered an endorsement. :plain:

We haven't had an actual, real leader in the White House since JFK. And look at what happened to him fifty-two years ago today.
 

Yorzhik

Well-known member
LIFETIME MEMBER
Hall of Fame
You still refuse to address the central point of my position.
Point 1 - Would training in an active shooting setting make you better able to respond appropriately if you ever end up in a real world shooting?
That was the CENTRAL point I addressed.

Point 2 - Do you really want somebody who is not trained firing a gun in your general direction?
No. But your proposal would increase the number of non-trained people. Think about it - what culture will have the most trained people carrying guns?: the gun culture or the only-special-people-are-allowed-to-have-guns culture?

Put yourself and your wife in that Paris theater. A gunman comes in the back and starts shooting. Somebody with a gun in the front who is scared to death pulls their gun and wildly starts shooting. Do you really want to be in the middle of that? Wouldn't you want somebody with some appropriate trading shooting past you?
Heck yeah I'd like someone with more training as opposed to someone with less training. But then again everyone in that theater sure would have preferred somebody, anybody, with a defensive gun as opposed to the slaughter that they got.

And a couple more points can be made. First, there has never been a defensive shooter at a shooting that "wildly starts shooting." They've all, even with little training, showed discretion commensurate with their skill. Even if you can find a case, the times where a non-trained person handled themselves well enough in a shooting to save lives is a very tall stack that your wild-shooters can ever reach.

And secondly, having a gun culture increases the chances that any random person will not only have a gun, but have some training to use it.
 

Nick M

Plymouth Colonist
LIFETIME MEMBER
Hall of Fame
This one happened this morning. "Heroic gunslinger" was not on the homeowners mind he shot the intruder during the home invasion.

The two men went to the back of the home and broke in through the back door. They were inside the home when an exchange of gunfire rang out. The homeowner shot and killed one of the would be burglars. The other suspect fled the scene.

The deceased burglar has been identified by his family as 19-year-old Tramel Day. Police have his gun. They have also taken the homeowner's gun in for evidence​
.
 

Nick M

Plymouth Colonist
LIFETIME MEMBER
Hall of Fame
This home owner was not thinking of some sort of heroic gunslinger fantasy when he had to shoot a man when his home was being invaded.

Madison County Sheriff John Lakin said the homeowner had every right to protect his property – and he did.

“At this point we still don`t know what the motive was here or what the suspect was thinking,” Lakin said.

So what advice is the sheriff offering?

“If you go into a home at 12:30 in the morning, it might be time to change professions,” he said.​
 

ok doser

lifeguard at the cement pond
i wonder if either of these homeowners stopped to think "gee, maybe i should have more training"
 

Crucible

BANNED
Banned
1476637_461128037325897_2127139553_n.jpg
 

Nick M

Plymouth Colonist
LIFETIME MEMBER
Hall of Fame
This one happened this morning. "Heroic gunslinger" was not on the homeowners mind he shot the intruder during the home invasion.

The two men went to the back of the home and broke in through the back door. They were inside the home when an exchange of gunfire rang out. The homeowner shot and killed one of the would be burglars. The other suspect fled the scene.

The deceased burglar has been identified by his family as 19-year-old Tramel Day. Police have his gun. They have also taken the homeowner's gun in for evidence​
.

One robber deceased courtesy of the home owner. The second has been caught and is being charged with attempted murder.
 

jgarden

BANNED
Banned
Ronald Reagan was long thought to be the most conservative of Republicans. And by any standard today he is the most popular Republican in modern history. Yet he

- raised taxes 11 times,

- supported a ban on assault rifles and the Brady Bill,

- which mandated background checks, and


- established amnesty for 3 million undocumented workers.

(Mark McKinnon)
 

Nick M

Plymouth Colonist
LIFETIME MEMBER
Hall of Fame
Ronald Reagan was long thought to be the most conservative of Republicans. And by any standard today he is the most popular Republican in modern history. Yet he

- raised taxes 11 times,

- supported a ban on assault rifles and the Brady Bill,

- which mandated background checks, and


- established amnesty for 3 million undocumented workers.

(Mark McKinnon)

Hmmm. I better vote for Hillary or Bernie. :plain:
 

jgarden

BANNED
Banned
Saddam was play footsie with UN inspectors wrt missles (defined by the UN as WMDs) that could reach Israel

Do you think he should have been allowed to develop the ability to deliver WMDs to Israel?
Document 52: Department of State Cable from George P. Shultz to the United States Embassy in Lebanon [et al.]. "Department Press Briefing, March 30, 1984," March 31, 1984.

The State Department announces it has imposed foreign policy controls on Iran and Iraq for exports of chemical weapons precursors. It responds to questions from the press about U.S. policy regarding the Iran-Iraq war, and a department spokesperson says Iraq's chemical weapons use will not change U.S. interest in pursuing closer U.S.-Iraq relations.

Source: Declassified under the Freedom of Information Acthttp://nsarchive.gwu.edu/NSAEBB/NSAEBB82/#docs

- a department (US State Department) spokesperson says Iraq's chemical weapons use will not change U.S. interest in pursuing closer U.S.-Iraq relations.

How quick conservatives like "ok doser" forget!

In 1984, the Reagan Administration (where GHW Bush served as Vice President) went on record as having no reservations about Saddam's chemical weapons - even when he was actively using them against the Iranians and his own people - the Kurds!

The Reagan Administration even tried to persuade its allies not to vote to condemn Iraq's use of chemical weapons by the United Nations.

The only time America decided that the world (and Israel) needed saving from WMD was when the they were looking for an excuse to invade Iraq after 9/11.
 
Top