Do you assume NO rich people are lazy? There are lazy people in every social class, the poor are likely less lazy on average than the others.
The principle of the scripture I posted is a mandate to give food to the poor, or allow them to take the leftovers from the rich. How is that not analogous to taxation and redistribution?
The problem is NOT that we shouldn't give to the poor (if they are working, then we can, but it is not required; if they are not, then we should not because a person who does not work should not eat, the reasoning behind that verse is that God knows that hunger is quite a motivator), it's that the Bible does not authorize the government, or any institution for that matter, to feed the poor on our behalf. For example, the Bible says that if a woman is widowed but under a certain age (the age given was 60 years old, which was very old at the time the passage was written) then the church SHOULD NOT support her, it should be her family that supports her. By having the government support her (or even the church), it tells the family that they don't have to support her, because the government can be expected to take care of her. It's like the lunch system in schools. The government is paying for the childrens' lunch? Why should I, the child's mother, prepare lunch, when it's free at the school, so the kid becomes malnourished because he's not getting the care his mother would be able to give him if she were the one making the lunch for him. She gives up responsibility for her child because she foolishly expects the government to be able to take care of her child. We could even take a step back from that and examine the effects of having a government run school system.
The problem here is that the government is currently overstepping it's God-given responsibilities, of which there are ONLY two: criminal justice/national defence and infrastructure. Anything else and the government starts to become inefficient, and can no longer fulfill it's proper roles, and that leads to am even greater decay in society.
Sent from my Pixel XL using
TheologyOnline mobile app