“No lie is of the truth” – Really?

dataylor

New member
The apostle John wrote how there is only one single Christian “truth”—and all who deny that single truth are not of God:

I have not written to you because you do not know the truth, but because you do know it, and because no lie is of the truth. Who is the liar but the one who denies that Jesus is the Christ? This is the antichrist [Greek: one who opposes Christ], the one who denies [Greek: contradicts] the Father and the Son. (I John 2:21-22).

Now watch as theologian Albert Barnes brilliantly unmasks our modern "Christianity," which is composed of thousands of differing and contradictory doctrines and beliefs:

“No lie is of the truth – No form of error, however plausible it may appear, however ingeniously it may be defended and however much it may seem to be favorable to human virtue and happiness, can be founded in truth. What the apostle says here has somewhat the aspect of a truism, but it contains a real truth of vital importance, and one which should have great influence in determining our minds in regard to any proposed opinion or doctrine.

Error often appears plausible. It seems to be adapted to relieve the mind of many difficulties which perplex and embarrass it on the subject of religion. It seems to be adapted to promote religion. It seems to make those who embrace it happy, and for a time they apparently enjoy religion. But John says that however plausible all this may be, however much it may seem to prove that the doctrines thus embraced are of God, it is a great and vital maxim that no error can have its foundation in truth, and, of course, that it must be worthless.

The grand question is, “what is truth;” and when that is determined, we can easily settle the inquiries which come up about the various doctrines that are abroad in the world. Mere plausible appearances, or temporary good results that may grow out of a doctrine, do not prove that it is based on truth; for whatever those results may be, it is impossible that any error, however plausible, should have its origin in the truth”


Perhaps Mr. Barnes has “nailed” the reason why organized Christianity favors the following beliefs, all of which are plainly contradicted by the words of Jesus Christ:

* That humans who die "lost" can never be saved and are condemned to Hell
* The acceptance of a hierarchical ministry in the Christian church
* A future Tribulation and Second Coming
* The view that states the thoughts of apostles carry the same weight as the words of Jesus Christ
* That people are called to Christ through solely through the work of evangelism

Your thoughts?
 

Bradley D

Well-known member
* That humans who die "lost" can never be saved and are condemned to Hell

Jesus came to save the "lost." The "lost" meaning fully destroy, cutting off entirely. I believe that the lost who refuse salvation will go to hell.

* The acceptance of a hierarchical ministry in the Christian church

Paul spoke of a hierarchy in the church and gave their requirements in his letters.

* A future Tribulation and Second Coming

Jesus and the apostles spoke of the tribulation and Second Coming. Therefore, I believe it.

* The view that states the thoughts of apostles carry the same weight as the words of Jesus Christ

The epistles in the NT were carefully added and accepted as scripture. Therefore, I accept them as scripture.

* That people are called to Christ through solely through the work of evangelism

I take evangelism to mean "preach" which Jesus wanted his disciples then and now to do. I guess someone could read a Bible on their own and be called. But that could also be considered a form of preaching also through the word.
 

Totton Linnet

New member
Silver Subscriber
The apostle John wrote how there is only one single Christian “truth”—and all who deny that single truth are not of God:

I have not written to you because you do not know the truth, but because you do know it, and because no lie is of the truth. Who is the liar but the one who denies that Jesus is the Christ? This is the antichrist [Greek: one who opposes Christ], the one who denies [Greek: contradicts] the Father and the Son. (I John 2:21-22).

Now watch as theologian Albert Barnes brilliantly unmasks our modern "Christianity," which is composed of thousands of differing and contradictory doctrines and beliefs:

“No lie is of the truth – No form of error, however plausible it may appear, however ingeniously it may be defended and however much it may seem to be favorable to human virtue and happiness, can be founded in truth. What the apostle says here has somewhat the aspect of a truism, but it contains a real truth of vital importance, and one which should have great influence in determining our minds in regard to any proposed opinion or doctrine.

Error often appears plausible. It seems to be adapted to relieve the mind of many difficulties which perplex and embarrass it on the subject of religion. It seems to be adapted to promote religion. It seems to make those who embrace it happy, and for a time they apparently enjoy religion. But John says that however plausible all this may be, however much it may seem to prove that the doctrines thus embraced are of God, it is a great and vital maxim that no error can have its foundation in truth, and, of course, that it must be worthless.

The grand question is, “what is truth;” and when that is determined, we can easily settle the inquiries which come up about the various doctrines that are abroad in the world. Mere plausible appearances, or temporary good results that may grow out of a doctrine, do not prove that it is based on truth; for whatever those results may be, it is impossible that any error, however plausible, should have its origin in the truth”


Perhaps Mr. Barnes has “nailed” the reason why organized Christianity favors the following beliefs, all of which are plainly contradicted by the words of Jesus Christ:

* That humans who die "lost" can never be saved and are condemned to Hell
* The acceptance of a hierarchical ministry in the Christian church
* A future Tribulation and Second Coming
* The view that states the thoughts of apostles carry the same weight as the words of Jesus Christ
* That people are called to Christ through solely through the work of evangelism

Your thoughts?

You seems to have picked up a few fibs yourself
 
Top