God's Exhaustive Foreknowledge

way 2 go

Well-known member
And?

The verse is about God's knowledge of His own works, not every future decision made by human beings.

And don't rip the verse out of its context. The immediate context is the Jerusalem Council, where they were trying to determine what to do about the Gentile believers and whether they needed to be circumcised and keep the Law of Moses.

James is discussing God's dealings with the Gentiles in accordance with His previously revealed purposes.

Even if the verse includes God's future works, how does knowing all His own works establish that He infallibly knows every future human choice?

Are you suggesting that every human action, including every sin, is one of God's works?
(Acts 15:18) All His works are known to God from eternity.

I noticed you acknowledge
God's past works , God's present works but when it comes to future works you change it and make it intentions and not works
So you think that that means that God makes people sin?

How?

God did not make anyone sin.

And we've already addressed Psalm 22. David's poetic description of his suffering foreshadows Christ's crucifixion.

Even if you insist that it is predictive prophecy, foreknowledge of a particular event does not establish exhaustive foreknowledge of every future human choice.
so Psalm 22 it is foreknowledge and God did not use his power to make them sin , got it
Just like I know you will freely choose to completely ignore any argument which resoundingly defeats your position.

And I'm definitely not God.
you have yet to make one

"Us in Him" is not talking about God selecting specific individuals independently of Christ.

God decided beforehand that WHOEVER is "in Christ" would be holy and without blame before Him in love.

He's describing His purpose for those who are in Christ.

That doesn't require knowing every individual who would eventually become part of that group.
saved people will be saved , really .

notice you skipped "before the foundation of the world" so you could skip the when.
(Ephesians 1:4) according as He chose us in Him before the foundation of the world, that we should be holy and without blame before Him in love,

when did God choose us , before we existed


Context context context!

Jesus is speaking DIRECTLY to His disciples about their appointment to bear fruit.

This is not a statement establishing exhaustive foreknowledge of every future human choice.
context , this is about freewill , which is most important to open theist .
(John 15:16) You have not chosen Me, but I have chosen you
I did address it. It's still there in your quotation of my post.

You not reading it doesn't mean I didn't address it.



There's your assumption. It's called begging the question. Can't do that.

The only thing required for God to choose "us in Him" before the foundation of the world is for Him to establish His purpose for whoever would eventually be in Christ.
their has to be a foreknowledge of "us" otherwise the statement is pointless

(Ephesians 1:4) according as He chose us in Him before the foundation of the world, that we should be holy and without blame before Him in love,
No. You're ignoring the context. "Whom He foreknew" is referring to the group named in the verse preceding verse 29:
(Romans 8:29) For whom He foreknew, means before you existed

the question isn't whom which is what you address , the question is about foreknowledge
and you ignore the foreknew
And we know that all things work together for good to those who love God, to those who are the called according to His purpose.
https://www.biblegateway.com/passage/?search=Romans 8:28&version=NKJV

"Those who love God, those who are the called according to His purpose."

Paul then describes God's purpose for that group: that they be conformed to the image of His Son.

And you still haven't established exhaustive foreknowledge of every future human choice.
and you avoid "foreknew" the part about foreknowledge

God calls those he foreknew

(Romans 8:28-30) [28] And we know that all things work together for good to those who love God, to those who are called according to His purpose. [29] For whom He foreknew, He also predestinated to be conformed to the image of His Son, for Him to be the First-born among many brothers. [30] But whom He predestinated, these He also called; and whom He called, those He also justified. And whom He justified, these He also glorified.
Again, context!

Paul is talking about Israel as God's covenant people.

In verse 1, Paul identifies himself as an Israelite, of the seed of Abraham, of the tribe of Benjamin.

Then he brings up Elijah and the seven thousand who had not bowed the knee to Baal.

And in verse 5:

Even so then, at this present time there is a remnant according to the election of grace.
https://www.biblegateway.com/passage/?search=Romans 11:5&version=NKJV

Paul is distinguishing Israel as God's covenant people from the faithful remnant within Israel.

And notice what Paul is actually arguing.

Has God cast away His people? Certainly not!

These are the people God had already known and chosen as His covenant people, the people with whom He had dealt throughout their history.
still not addressing "foreknew" you keep focusing on the who , why do you do that ?
the foreknowledge is the question

These are the people God had already foreknew
(Romans 11:2) God did not thrust out His people whom He foreknew.
God hasn't forgotten Israel or His promises to them simply because many Israelites have rejected Christ.

The "foreknowledge" in this passage concerns God's prior knowledge of and relationship with Israel as His people. Paul isn't defining exhaustive knowledge of every future human choice.
you explain history ,it's not history ,it's foreknowledge
God is talking about people like Paul that God chose by foreknowledge and Jewish believers , the remnant God foreknew
You're taking the word "foreknew" and assuming it means God knew every future action of every Israelite from eternity past.

That's not what Paul is arguing.
you dismiss foreknowledge with your eisegesis every time you see it
and you haven't addressed "foreknowledge" yet , talked around it a lot
Peter is writing to the elect sojourners of the Dispersion, identified in verse 1.

Their election is according to God's foreknowledge, through sanctification of the Spirit, unto obedience and the sprinkling of Christ's blood.

And where does Peter establish that God knows every future free choice of every human being?

(Hint: he doesn't.)
yes , "Their election is according to God's foreknowledge"
God foreknew the elect when ?


God knew who he was going to do a good work in them from eternity

exhaustive infallible foreknowledge
(Acts 15:18) All His works are known to God from eternity.
one type of work that God knows about
(Philippians 1:6) being confident of this very thing, that He who has begun a good work in you will perform it until the day of Jesus Christ,
Saying it doesn't make it so!

And how could they believe that when God Himself indicates the future is uncertain by saying perhaps, by chance, lest, etc.?


"Perhaps everyone will listen and turn [repent, so] that I may repent concerning the calamity which I purpose to bring on them" Jer. 26:3; "Then the Lord God said, '...now, lest he put out his hand and take also of the tree of life, and eat, and live forever' therefore the Lord God sent him out of the garden... and He placed cherubim at the east of the garden of Eden... to guard the way to the tree of life" Gen. 3:22-24; "Then it came to pass, when Pharaoh had let the people go, that God did not lead them by way of the land of the Philistines, although that was near; for God said, 'Lest perhaps the people change their mind and return to Egypt' " Ex. 13:17; if the Egyptians "do not believe you nor heed the message of the first sign, that they may believe the message of the latter sign. And it shall be, if they do not believe even these two signs, or listen to your voice, that you shall take water from the river and pour it on the dry land. The water... will become blood" Ex. 4:8-9 (the Bible doesn't record but Egypt's secular writing does that indeed it did come to this, when Moses poured the water on the ground); "do not let the priests and the people break through to come up to the Lord, lest He break out against them" Ex. 19:24; "For if God did not spare the natural branches [Israel], He may not spare you either [the Gentiles]. Therefore consider the goodness and severity of God: on those who fell, severity; but toward you, goodness, if you continue in His goodness. Otherwise you also will be cut off. And they also [Israel], if they do not continue in unbelief, will be grafted in, for God is able to graft them in again" Rom. 11:21-23 by which Paul explains that God could graft national Israel back in again as His covenant people, and being God (who could stop Him?) He could bring to a premature end to His covenant with the Body of Christ (at which point He'd either return to His covenant of circumcision or do something new); "If she had not [Heb. perhaps] turned aside from Me, surely I would also have killed you by now, and let her live" Num. 22:33; "It may be [Heb. perhaps] that the house of Judah will hear all the adversities which I purpose to bring upon them, that everyone may turn from his evil way, that I may forgive their iniquity and their sin" Jer. 36:3 showing the extent and significance of the possibilities; “They sow the wind, and reap the whirlwind... the stalk... shall never produce meal [but] if [Heb. perhaps] it should produce, aliens [foreigners] would swallow it up" Hos. 8:7; "The Lord said, "Indeed the people are one... and this is what they begin to do; now nothing they propose to do will be withheld from them" Gen. 11:6; perhaps regarding Israel, "it may be that they will consider" and repent Ezek. 12:3; "by chance a certain priest came down that road [to Jericho] Luke 10:31; "Sin no more lest a worse thing come upon you" John 5:14; "if you do not drive out the inhabitants of the land... it shall be that I will do to you as I thought to do to them Num. 33:55-56 (that is, God threatened to cast out Israel, as happened by the Assyrian and Babylonian captivities, instead of casting out the pagan nations); "Then they drew near to the village where they were going, and He [ Jesus ] indicated that He would have gone farther. But they constrained Him saying, 'Abide with us...' and He went in to stay with them" Luke 24:28-29; "Now about the fourth watch of the night He came to them, walking on the sea, and would have passed them by" except that His disciples cried out and He replied to them Mark 6:48; "Therefore let him who thinks he stands take heed lest he fall" 1 Cor. 10:12; and see Ezek. 7:23-24, the future now being different from what it would have been, but for their bloody crime.



How do you account for these passages within your claim that every future human choice is already infallibly known?
God speaks to humans in human ways , God gives us choices while knowing what we will choose
perhaps , could be , are persuasion techniques

do you know how therapy works , by asking questions to lead people to the right answers
God does the same thing, that is to say God ask Question he knows the answers to

parents do the same thing.
We've been over this one, way 2 go. Did you forget already?

The immediate context concerns David's development in his mother's womb.

And even if the reference to his days is understood as concerning his future lifespan, that still doesn't establish exhaustive, infallible foreknowledge of every future human choice.
it is more foreknowledge , that you don't address
(Psalms 139:16) Thine eyes saw my unformed substance, and in thy book they were all written, even the days that were ordained, when as yet there was none of them.
Notice that God says "formed," not "conceived." Those are two different concepts.

God knew Jeremiah (post-conception) and appointed him to be a prophet to the nations.

Setting someone apart for a particular purpose does not require infallibly knowing every decision that person will ever make.

it is more foreknowledge , that you don't address , I'm seeing a pattern.
and " before I formed thee" would be preconception , after conception everything is already there
(Jeremiah 1:5) Before I formed thee in the belly I knew thee, and before thou came forth out of the womb I sanctified thee. I have appointed thee a prophet to the nations
Saying it doesn't make it so.

Supra.
(Acts 15:18) All His works are known to God from eternity.

the verse implies it , if you think about ,
the verse says "All His works are known to God from eternity."

All past , present and future : All God has done , is doing , will do , are known to God from eternity

takes exhaustive infallible foreknowledge to know about all his works in peoples lives that he will do in future



And?

Notice that God has already begun this work. Paul is expressing confidence that God will complete what He has begun.

God knowing what He intends to accomplish doesn't require knowing every choice the Philippians will make along the way.

Nor does knowledge of a particular future outcome establish exhaustive foreknowledge of every future human choice.
(Philippians 1:6) being confident of this very thing, that He who has begun a good work in you will perform it until the day of Jesus Christ,

yes , "Notice that God has already begun this work," and this verse shows God with (Acts 15:18)
God foreknows all the works that he will do in future of each believer .

all of the future works in all of them .

not intent, not might do , foreknowledge of what God will do , works

The meaning and scope of "all" are determined by context.

For example, do you really believe that the entirety of "Jerusalem, Judea, and all the region around the Jordan" came out to be baptized in the Jordan by John the Baptist?

Then Jerusalem, all Judea, and all the region around the Jordan went out to him and were baptized by him in the Jordan, confessing their sins.
https://www.biblegateway.com/passage/?search=Matthew 3:5-6&version=NKJV

Clearly, "all" doesn't mean every individual without exception. Luke 7:29-30 explicitly identifies people who were not baptized by John, including the Pharisees and lawyers.

But when he saw many of the Pharisees and Sadducees coming to his baptism, he said to them, “Brood of vipers! Who warned you to flee from the wrath to come? Therefore bear fruits worthy of repentance, and do not think to say to yourselves, ‘We have Abraham as our father. ’ For I say to you that God is able to raise up children to Abraham from these stones. And even now the ax is laid to the root of the trees. Therefore every tree which does not bear good fruit is cut down and thrown into the fire. I indeed baptize you with water unto repentance, but He who is coming after me is mightier than I, whose sandals I am not worthy to carry. He will baptize you with the Holy Spirit and fire. His winnowing fan is in His hand, and He will thoroughly clean out His threshing floor, and gather His wheat into the barn; but He will burn up the chaff with unquenchable fire. ”
https://www.biblegateway.com/passage/?search=Matthew 3:7-12&version=NKJV

And when all the people heard Him, even the tax collectors justified God, having been baptized with the baptism of John. But the Pharisees and lawyers rejected the will of God for themselves, not having been baptized by him.
https://www.biblegateway.com/passage/?search=Luke 7:29-30&version=NKJV

So "all" must be understood according to its context.

But even granting that Acts 15:18 means literally every single one of God's works, you're ignoring the qualification.

All HIS works.

Not all future human choices.

You're treating the word "all" as though it has no limitation whatsoever, despite the verse explicitly identifying what it refers to.
we're talking about God , it's not hyperbole when he says
(Acts 15:18) All His works are known to God from eternity.


all God's works takes into account all human choices
that is how God knows what his works would be from eternity
Not what the verse says.

As already explained, the context concerns God's longstanding works and purposes, particularly His dealings with Israel and the Gentiles.

God hasn't forgotten what He's done, what He's promised, or what He intends to accomplish.

You're assuming the passage describes His infallible knowledge of every future action, rather than demonstrating that interpretation from the text.
it is not intends ,not purposes , you keep doing that
(Acts 15:18) All His works are known to God from eternity.
You are very confused.

If not, then demonstrate that you understand the distinction between God's knowledge of His own works and exhaustive knowledge of every future human choice.
all God's works takes into account all human choices
that is how God knows what his works would be from eternity
So you're saying that your existence and membership in the Body of Christ were already infallibly settled before creation?

That you could never have failed to exist, or freely chosen not to become someone "in Christ," given God's supposedly fixed, infallible foreknowledge?

Do you realize what that does to your claim that people freely choose whether to accept Christ?

Do you not realize how arrogant you sound?
are you saying God is arrogant ?

(John 15:16) You have not chosen Me, but I have chosen you
(I Peter 1:2) Elect according to the foreknowledge of God the Father, through sanctification of the Spirit, to obedience and sprinkling of the blood of Jesus Christ: Grace to you, and peace, be multiplied
(Ephesians 1:4) According as he has chosen us in him before the foundation of the world, that we should be holy and without blame before him in love
No. Jesus chose Judas because he knew what kind of man he was, especialy after the three years he spent interacting with him on a personal level.

John 6:64-71 makes that clear.

But Jesus knowing Judas's character, and even knowing that Judas would betray Him, does not establish exhaustive, infallible foreknowledge of every future human choice.

God accomplished His purpose through Judas's actions without thereby needing exhaustive knowledge of every decision every human being would ever make.
didn't make Judas sin . foreknowledge , just limited , but is it really limited ? no . what limits it ? nothing

(Acts 15:18) All His works are known to God from eternity.
And?

The passage concerns governing authority and those who exercise it.

God establishing governing authority doesn't require Him to predetermine every individual who will hold office or every decision those individuals will make.

Read the following verses. Paul is discussing the responsibility of rulers to punish evil and approve what is good.

How does that establish that God infallibly knows every future decision made by every ruler?

It doesn't.

Once again, you're confusing God's authority and His purposes with exhaustive foreknowledge of human choices.
context , this is about freewill , which is most important to open theist .
(Romans 13:1) Let every soul be subject to the higher authorities. For there is no authority but of God; the authorities that exist are ordained by God.

And?

Nobody is disputing that God initiated His plan of salvation and established its terms.

That doesn't mean He infallibly knew every individual who would respond to Him, much less every future decision those individuals would make.



You never answered my question.

Is God free to change the future He infallibly knows about?

If He already infallibly knows that He will do A tomorrow, is He free to choose B instead?

And if not, in what sense is God free to do otherwise?
does God make mistakes
(Matthew 5:48) Therefore be perfect, even as your Father in Heaven is perfect.
And even if you could establish that God knows every future work He will perform in believers generally, you'd still need to explain how that establishes exhaustive foreknowledge of every future choice made by every human being.
(Acts 15:18) All His works are known to God from eternity.

all God's works takes into account all human choices
that is how God knows what his works would be from eternity
 

way 2 go

Well-known member
This is absolutely hilarious coming from you.

YOU are the one that claims that God knows every thought and action that a person will make or take... EVEN BEFORE THEY EXIST.

Talk about "foreknowledge in a vacuum"!
(Acts 15:18) All His works are known to God from eternity.


all God's works takes into account all human choices
that is how God knows what his works would be from eternity
 

JudgeRightly

裁判官が正しく判断する
Staff member
Administrator
Super Moderator
Gold Subscriber
(Acts 15:18) All His works are known to God from eternity.

Already addressed. Repeating the verse does not advance your argument.

I noticed you acknowledge
God's past works , God's present works but when it comes to future works you change it and make it intentions and not works

Because future works haven't been performed yet.

There's a difference between what God has already accomplished, what He is presently doing, and what He intends to accomplish in the future.

God can know precisely what He intends to accomplish and possess the power to ensure that it happens without infallibly knowing every human choice made along the way.

And some of God's future works are explicitly conditional upon human conduct. Jeremiah 18:7-10 makes that abundantly clear.

so Psalm 22 it is foreknowledge and God did not use his power to make them sin , got it

No, you don't "got it."

I explained that Psalm 22 can be understood as typological foreshadowing, and that EVEN IF we grant your interpretation that it predicts specific future events, it still doesn't establish exhaustive, infallible foreknowledge.

You're taking a hypothetical concession and pretending it's an admission that your argument is correct.

It isn't.

you have yet to make one

The entire thread is still here for everyone to read, way 2 go. Stop lying.

saved people will be saved , really .

No.

Those who are in Him will be saved.

Just as an airline says that all who board this plane in Los Angeles will be taken to Atlanta. The airline doesn't know who will be on the flight until the person buys the ticket and boards the plane. They just know that whoever is on the plane will be taken from point A to point B...

So too, Paul is saying that those who are "in Him" will be made holy and blameless.

notice you skipped "before the foundation of the world" so you could skip the when.
(Ephesians 1:4) according as He chose us in Him before the foundation of the world, that we should be holy and without blame before Him in love,

when did God choose us , before we existed

Not "us," period.

"Us in Him."

It's a group, one grounded in Christ.

Christ is the one who existed before the foundation of the world. God determined before the foundation of the world that anyone and everyone who puts their faith in Christ would be counted among those "in Him" and would be holy and blameless before Him.

That is the purpose God established beforehand.

The passage doesn't say God infallibly knew the identity and every future decision of every individual who would eventually belong to that group.

You're confusing God's prior determination of what would be true of those in Christ with the claim that He infallibly knew every individual who would eventually enter Christ.

context , this is about freewill , which is most important to open theist .
(John 15:16) You have not chosen Me, but I have chosen you

Addressed. This is Jesus speaking directly to His disciples. They were chosen for a purpose, to be His disciples.

their has to be a foreknowledge of "us" otherwise the statement is pointless

(Ephesians 1:4) according as He chose us in Him before the foundation of the world, that we should be holy and without blame before Him in love,

Supra.

(Romans 8:29) For whom He foreknew, means before you existed

No.

"Foreknew" doesn't mean "exhaustively and infallibly knew every future decision you would make before you existed."

Romans 8:29 identifies those whom God foreknew and what He predestined them to become: conformed to the image of His Son.

You keep inserting exhaustive foreknowledge of every future human choice into passages that don't say anything of the sort.

the question isn't whom which is what you address , the question is about foreknowledge
and you ignore the foreknew

I didn't. I've explained it already. See post #54.

and you avoid "foreknew" the part about foreknowledge

Supra.

God calls those he foreknew

(Romans 8:28-30) [28] And we know that all things work together for good to those who love God, to those who are called according to His purpose. [29] For whom He foreknew, He also predestinated to be conformed to the image of His Son, for Him to be the First-born among many brothers. [30] But whom He predestinated, these He also called; and whom He called, those He also justified. And whom He justified, these He also glorified.

And what, precisely, does God predestinate them to?

"To be conformed to the image of His Son."

That's the stated purpose.

You keep emphasizing the word "foreknew" while ignoring both its object and what the passage actually says God predestined.

Even if you could establish that God foreknew particular individuals before their existence, that still wouldn't establish that He infallibly knew every decision they would ever make.

You're assuming that foreknowledge of people necessarily means exhaustive foreknowledge of their actions.

It doesn't.

still not addressing "foreknew" you keep focusing on the who , why do you do that ?
the foreknowledge is the question

Supra.

These are the people God had already foreknew
(Romans 11:2) God did not thrust out His people whom He foreknew.

Again, talking about Israel. Supra.

you explain history ,it's not history ,it's foreknowledge

The Bible is a history book.

It tells a story. If you ignore the story just to uphold your beliefs, then something is wrong with your theology.

God is talking about people like Paul that God chose by foreknowledge and Jewish believers , the remnant God foreknew

Romans 11:1-5 concerns God's dealings with Israel, His covenant people, and the remnant that remains according to the election of grace.

Paul's point is that God has not cast away the people He previously knew and dealt with.

That's why he immediately refers to Elijah and the history of Israel.

You're treating God's previous knowledge of His covenant people as though it means God infallibly knew every future decision of every Israelite before creation.

The text doesn't say that.

you dismiss foreknowledge with your eisegesis every time you see it
and you haven't addressed "foreknowledge" yet , talked around it a lot

Supra.

yes , "Their election is according to God's foreknowledge"
God foreknew the elect when ?

The passage says their election is according to God's foreknowledge.

It doesn't say that God infallibly knew every choice every elect person would ever make.

Once again, you're confusing the object of God's foreknowledge with the supposed exhaustiveness of that knowledge.

Even knowledge of a person's future election would not, by itself, establish knowledge of every action that person would ever perform.

God knew who he was going to do a good work in them from eternity

Where does Scripture actually say that God knew every future individual in whom He would begin that work from eternity?

exhaustive infallible foreknowledge
(Acts 15:18) All His works are known to God from eternity.
one type of work that God knows about
(Philippians 1:6) being confident of this very thing, that He who has begun a good work in you will perform it until the day of Jesus Christ,

Repeating yourself doesn't advance your position.

God speaks to humans in human ways ,

And?

God gives us choices while knowing what we will choose

Saying it doesn't make it so.

perhaps , could be , are persuasion techniques

Persuasion only makes sense if the person could do otherwise, which YOUR POSITION precludes by necessity.

It presupposes that someone's response can be influenced. But if God already infallibly knows exactly how that person will respond, then, given that fixed prior knowledge, the person cannot respond otherwise.

You're treating persuasion as though the person has genuinely open alternatives while insisting that only one response can actually occur.

do you know how therapy works , by asking questions to lead people to the right answers
God does the same thing, that is to say God ask Question he knows the answers to

parents do the same thing.

And nobody disputes that God can ask questions He already knows the answers to.

But that's not the issue.

There's a difference between asking someone a question to prompt reflection and expressing uncertainty about what someone WILL do.

There's also a difference between asking a question and declaring, after administering a test, "NOW I KNOW."

You can't simply assume that every statement God makes about His knowledge, His expectations, or the possibility of a future outcome is merely a teaching technique.

You need to demonstrate that from the context of the passages in question.

it is more foreknowledge , that you don't address
(Psalms 139:16) Thine eyes saw my unformed substance, and in thy book they were all written, even the days that were ordained, when as yet there was none of them.

We've been over this one too, way 2 go.

Psalm 139 is about fetology, the development of the baby in the womb, not exhaustive foreknowledge about a person's entire life.

it is more foreknowledge , that you don't address , I'm seeing a pattern.

The only pattern here is that I address something you say, you ignore it, present a different verse, a different argument, which I then address, only for you to return to the first argument, as though I never addressed it, and then you have the gall to say that I have yet to make an argument that defeats your position. Rinse and repeat.

and " before I formed thee" would be preconception , after conception everything is already there
(Jeremiah 1:5) Before I formed thee in the belly I knew thee, and before thou came forth out of the womb I sanctified thee. I have appointed thee a prophet to the nations

No.

Conception and formation are not synonymous.

A human being begins to exist at conception, but the physical development and formation of that individual continue afterward.

God could therefore know Jeremiah after conception, but before his physical formation had progressed, without knowing him before he existed.

And consider the problem your interpretation introduces.

Before Jeremiah's conception, his existence depended upon events and human choices that, under a genuinely open future, had not yet occurred.

What actually existing Jeremiah was there for God to know before Jeremiah existed?

You're simply assuming that Jeremiah's future existence was already an infallibly settled fact.

But that's the very point in dispute.

(Acts 15:18) All His works are known to God from eternity.

Supra.

the verse implies it , if you think about ,
the verse says "All His works are known to God from eternity."

No, it doesn't.

And anyone who actually thinks about it, instead of just mindlessly assuming whatever one has been taught to believe it says, would realize very quickly that it doesn't mean what you say it means.

All past , present and future : All God has done , is doing , will do , are known to God from eternity

Repeating yourself does not advance your argument.

takes exhaustive infallible foreknowledge to know about all his works in peoples lives that he will do in future

Why?

If God decides to accomplish a particular work in someone's life, why must He know every future choice that person will make?

He can know what He intends to accomplish, possess the ability to accomplish it, and respond to the person's choices as they occur.

You're still asserting a logical necessity that you haven't demonstrated.

(Philippians 1:6) being confident of this very thing, that He who has begun a good work in you will perform it until the day of Jesus Christ,

Supra.

yes , "Notice that God has already begun this work," and this verse shows God with (Acts 15:18)
God foreknows all the works that he will do in future of each believer .

Philippians 1:6 expresses confidence that God will complete the good work He has begun.

It doesn't say God infallibly knew every future choice of those believers before they existed.

Nor does it say that God's ability to complete His work depends upon exhaustive foreknowledge of their decisions.

You're adding those claims to the text.

all of the future works in all of them .

not intent, not might do , foreknowledge of what God will do , works

You keep confusing God's certainty concerning His purposes with exhaustive knowledge of every future human choice.

God can determine that He WILL accomplish something.

And He can know what He will do if a person responds one way or another.

Neither proposition establishes that He infallibly knows every choice the person will make.

we're talking about God , it's not hyperbole when he says
(Acts 15:18) All His works are known to God from eternity.

Supra.

all God's works takes into account all human choices

Supra.

that is how God knows what his works would be from eternity

Supra.

it is not intends ,not purposes , you keep doing that

Because God's works don't occur independently of His purposes and intentions.

What God intends to accomplish is directly relevant to what He will do.

And where God expressly makes His actions conditional upon human conduct, you can't simply ignore that conditionality and declare the outcome infallibly settled.

Read Jeremiah 18:7-10.

(Acts 15:18) All His works are known to God from eternity.

all God's works takes into account all human choices
that is how God knows what his works would be from eternity

Repeating yourself does not advance your argument.

are you saying God is arrogant ?

The question was directed at you.

Do you not realize how arrogant you sound right now?

(John 15:16) You have not chosen Me, but I have chosen you
(I Peter 1:2) Elect according to the foreknowledge of God the Father, through sanctification of the Spirit, to obedience and sprinkling of the blood of Jesus Christ: Grace to you, and peace, be multiplied
(Ephesians 1:4) According as he has chosen us in him before the foundation of the world, that we should be holy and without blame before him in love

Three passages about choosing and election.

None establishes exhaustive, infallible foreknowledge of every future human choice.

John 15:16 concerns Christ choosing His disciples and appointing them to bear fruit.

1 Peter 1:2 concerns the election of believers according to God's foreknowledge.

Ephesians 1:4 concerns God's choice of those who are "in Him" to be holy and blameless.

You still haven't established that God's choosing people for particular purposes requires infallible knowledge of every future decision they will make.

didn't make Judas sin .

Nobody said God made Judas sin.

The question is whether Judas could have chosen otherwise, given your claim that God already infallibly knew his betrayal.

If God's prior knowledge was fixed and infallible, how could Judas have done anything different without God's knowledge having been different?

You're responding to an argument about necessity as though it were an argument about causation.

They're not the same thing.

foreknowledge , just limited , but is it really limited ? no . what limits it ? nothing

You're assuming that exhaustive foreknowledge of a future that doesn't yet exist is the measure of God's knowledge.

But God knowing everything that can be known doesn't require that every future human choice already be a settled fact.

If a future decision is genuinely undetermined, there is no presently settled outcome of that decision to know infallibly.

That's not a limitation on God's ability to know.

It's a distinction between what is actual, what is possible, and what has not yet been decided.

(Acts 15:18) All His works are known to God from eternity.

Supra.

context , this is about freewill , which is most important to open theist .

No.

What's important is understanding what Scripture actually teaches about God and His relationship with mankind.

You're the one insisting that people possess free will while simultaneously claiming that every decision they will ever make is already infallibly known.

So answer the question.

Given God's fixed, infallible prior knowledge of a person's decision, can that person genuinely choose otherwise?

If not, in what sense is the alternative genuinely open to them?

(Romans 13:1) Let every soul be subject to the higher authorities. For there is no authority but of God; the authorities that exist are ordained by God.

Supra.

does God make mistakes
(Matthew 5:48) Therefore be perfect, even as your Father in Heaven is perfect.

No.

Now answer the question I actually asked.
If God already infallibly knows that He will do A tomorrow, is He free to choose B instead?

Changing one's intended course of action in response to changing circumstances isn't necessarily a mistake.

Jeremiah 18:7-10 explicitly describes God changing what He intends to do in response to human conduct.

So why are you treating God's ability to act differently as though it would necessarily constitute an error?

And if God cannot do otherwise than what He already infallibly knows He will do, how is His own future genuinely open to alternative choices?

(Acts 15:18) All His works are known to God from eternity.

all God's works takes into account all human choices
that is how God knows what his works would be from eternity

Repeating yourself does not advance your argument.
 

Derf

Well-known member
Revelation of John 16:8-9 [8] And the fourth angel poured out his vial upon the sun; and power was given unto him to scorch men with fire. [9] And men were scorched with great heat, and blasphemed the name of God, which hath power over these plagues: and they repented not to give him glory.

I don't agree . why would you call "sins" "His works" ?

foreknowledge is not a force


no
(Acts 15:18) All His works are known to God from eternity.

in order for God to know all His works from eternity God would have to know all our works ,which God does which is why (Acts 15:18) All His works are known to God from eternity.
Ok, I see what you are saying. If God responds to something we do, then His response is one of His works, and He had to have known what we would do in order to respond in the preplanned way.

It seems to me that you still have the problem of knowing what, say, "Bob" will do before he exists. Somebody besides Bob must have made a decision what Bob will do. It couldn't have been Bob, since he doesn't exist yet. And if God only knows what Bob will do, but doesn't cause it (because Bob is a sinner, God can't be the one causing his sins) somebody else must have made that decision, somebody that existed in the beginning with God, but is not God. Foreknowledge is not causative, but for foreknowledge to be infallible, the events must all be determined by the time the knowledge is reliable, which happened before Bob came into existence. Bob, therefore, was not the determiner of his decisions.

If you don't believe that God was the determiner, then you are not a Calvinist, you are an Arminian. The problem with your Arminian view, unfortunately, is that the determined (not God, but who has existed as long as God) now has power over Bob's decisions and over God's, because he forces God's hand by first determining what Bob will do, and then God is playing a role decided for Him by that other entity.
 
Top