6 Rules for Thinking Like a CIA Analyst to Beat Fake News

The Barbarian

BANNED
Banned
Know Thyself
It’s here were a news consumer has to watch out for “confirmation bias” — reading or watching only the sources of news that you already agree with.

...

Know the Outlet Doing the Reporting
“In the age of digital media, new sources of information pop up every day; it’s important to understand the source of the information. This is more than just understanding if the news source is politically left-leaning or right-leaning. Analysts look at whether or not the organization putting out the information has a political goal or if it is a traditional news source,” Otis said.

...

Know the Journalist Doing the Reporting
On a related point, Otis said readers should take some time to learn a bit about the author or commentator giving them the news and whether they have a background in the topic area.

...

Don’t Blindly Trust Sources, Assess Them
Diving into the meat of the story itself, readers should pay particular attention to the sources cited and how their background is relevant to the subject at hand.

...

Slow Down, You Might Discover Non-Stories
In the lightning-fast 24-hour news cycle, it’s easy to see blockbuster news reports coming one after the other. The problem is that it can leave little time for the news organization and others, much less the average citizen, to examine any one thing for very long.

Otis says it’s still important to consciously slow down and take the time to do some research.

Seriously, Slow Down and Don’t Be Part of the Problem
“It’s more important than ever before to make sure you’re not part of the disinformation problem,” Otis said.

That means taking a breath before clicking “retweet” on Twitter or “share” on Facebook and running through the above steps.

“Resist the impulse to retweet now based off a headline and read later (or maybe not at all),” Otis said. “If there’s something you don’t know, take the time to do the research.”


And if you read something that you really, really want to be true, that's the time to be most skeptical. Read the article; it's worth the time.
 

Grosnick Marowbe

New member
Hall of Fame
Know Thyself
It’s here were a news consumer has to watch out for “confirmation bias” — reading or watching only the sources of news that you already agree with.

...

Know the Outlet Doing the Reporting
“In the age of digital media, new sources of information pop up every day; it’s important to understand the source of the information. This is more than just understanding if the news source is politically left-leaning or right-leaning. Analysts look at whether or not the organization putting out the information has a political goal or if it is a traditional news source,” Otis said.

...

Know the Journalist Doing the Reporting
On a related point, Otis said readers should take some time to learn a bit about the author or commentator giving them the news and whether they have a background in the topic area.

...

Don’t Blindly Trust Sources, Assess Them
Diving into the meat of the story itself, readers should pay particular attention to the sources cited and how their background is relevant to the subject at hand.

...

Slow Down, You Might Discover Non-Stories
In the lightning-fast 24-hour news cycle, it’s easy to see blockbuster news reports coming one after the other. The problem is that it can leave little time for the news organization and others, much less the average citizen, to examine any one thing for very long.

Otis says it’s still important to consciously slow down and take the time to do some research.

Seriously, Slow Down and Don’t Be Part of the Problem
“It’s more important than ever before to make sure you’re not part of the disinformation problem,” Otis said.

That means taking a breath before clicking “retweet” on Twitter or “share” on Facebook and running through the above steps.

“Resist the impulse to retweet now based off a headline and read later (or maybe not at all),” Otis said. “If there’s something you don’t know, take the time to do the research.”


And if you read something that you really, really want to be true, that's the time to be most skeptical. Read the article; it's worth the time.

Our nation is DIVIDED. You'd have to be quite NAIVE to believe there's ANY news agencies that are totally unbiased. Most media outlets today, lean to the far-left. In order to deny that fact, you'd be trying to DELUDE yourself. Come on Barb, you're gonna have to do better than this?
 

The Barbarian

BANNED
Banned
Our nation is DIVIDED. You'd have to be quite NAIVE to believe there's ANY news agencies that are totally unbiased.

Hence the advice above. Consider the source always, and especially if it's something you really want to believe, go and check it elsewhere.

Most far-right believers think that most media are far-left. It makes sense to them, because they believe most Americans are far-left.

If it's any comfort to you, I had no illusions that you would take the advice. It's for rational people, who might read it and consider the issue rationally.
 

Grosnick Marowbe

New member
Hall of Fame
Hence the advice above. Consider the source always, and especially if it's something you really want to believe, go and check it elsewhere.

Most far-right believers think that most media are far-left. It makes sense to them, because they believe most Americans are far-left.

If it's any comfort to you, I had no illusions that you would take the advice. It's for rational people, who might read it and consider the issue rationally.


Oh, you mean people who are permanently in a persistent vegetative state?
 

Gary K

New member
Banned
Our nation is DIVIDED. You'd have to be quite NAIVE to believe there's ANY news agencies that are totally unbiased. Most media outlets today, lean to the far-left. In order to deny that fact, you'd be trying to DELUDE yourself. Come on Barb, you're gonna have to do better than this?

Barby's quote is his idea of a joke. He's being funny, actually. To be a deep state operator is his idea of being thoughtful and well-balanced. It's actually pretty funny that he quotes the mockingbird media to say that thinking like a cia agent is the way to find out the truth. In other words his idea of knowing truth is to delve as deeply into distributing falsehood as possible. When you think about it is a pretty ironic conclusion.
 

The Barbarian

BANNED
Banned
Barby's quote is his idea of a joke. He's being funny, actually. To be a deep state operator is his idea of being thoughtful and well-balanced. It's actually pretty funny that he quotes the mockingbird media to say that thinking like a cia agent is the way to find out the truth.

Rational skepticism is always a good idea. And when someone tells you something you really want to be true, that's when you should be most cautious. You're the easiest person for you to fool, and that's exactly why you need to be careful.

And I can see why you react so strongly against that advice. So can everyone else. Learn to think for yourself, and you won't be so easy to fool.
 

rexlunae

New member
Our nation is DIVIDED. You'd have to be quite NAIVE to believe there's ANY news agencies that are totally unbiased. Most media outlets today, lean to the far-left. In order to deny that fact, you'd be trying to DELUDE yourself. Come on Barb, you're gonna have to do better than this?

That's a false equivalence. There's no one who is unbiased. But that isn't the standard. You have to understand and anticipate biases, including your own, and evaluate sources based on actually attainable standards, such as a pattern of honesty, cogency, and reliability.
 
Top